Beck, Chris. Febuary 18 2006. ‘The Pwerle Sisters,’ The Age, Arts Review, Australia.
Lacey, Stephen. 6 November 2004. ‘Barbara Weir & Minnie Pwerle,’ The Sydney Morning Herald, Good Weekend.
McCulloch, Susan. 8 November 2003. ‘All in the Family,’ The Australian.
Ryan, Judith. Colour Power - Aboriginal Art Post 1984, National Gallery of Victoria, Melbourne, 2004.
Minnie Pwerle painted only during the last seven years of her life, yet her output was prodigious. Her colorful expressive works seemed tailor-made to meet the market demand for vibrant gestural paintings left vacant by the death of her countrywoman, Emily Kngwarreye. She created her earliest paintings in 1999, and they could be found in shops, retailers, and galleries all over the country. By 2002, her first works began appearing on the secondary market but, with so many paintings produced in such a short and intense period, an uneven output and reports of fakery were not uncommon.
While the Aboriginal art market was in a buoyant state, the speculative atmosphere at the time made it difficult for anyone other than those closest to Minnie, to differentiate between her finest works and the large amount of repetitive imagery she produced. As a result, when her paintings began to appear at auction, the results were nothing short of catastrophic. Collectors, quite obviously, did not take her work seriously. Her presence in the secondary market began inauspiciously. With Minnie continuing to supply an ever ready and uneducated primary market, 35 works were offered at auction over 2004 and 2005; 32 failed to sell. Under normal circumstances most auction houses and collectors would have seen this as the kiss of death, but there were several fine art galleries that had sold exceptional works by the artist.
Believing that she had been ill-served by the mediocre paintings that had found their way into the secondary market at that time, they began feeding it with higher quality works through Lawson~Menzies sales. Perhaps one work alone pointed to a far different future for the artist in the secondary market. Despite the appalling results of 2004, Lawson~Menzies November auction sold an exceptional example of the artist’s best early painting. Awelye Atnwengerrp 2000, measuring 360 x 166 cm, for $43,200. This result marked the beginning of an incredible turnaround.
Sales during the next three years following her death in 2006 were nothing short of spectacular and were due entirely to a curatorial reassessment of her oeuvre by Lawson~Menzies, who had sold every one of her top ten results and all but three of her top 20 by the end of that period. In what was a complete turnabout, 55 works were offered in 2006 and 2007 of which 43 were successful. In 2007 alone, Lawson~Menzies posted the artist’s best, third, fourth, fifth, eighth, ninth and tenth-highest results. A new record was set in November 2007 for a relatively early work Awelye Atnwengerrp, 2002 (measuring 165 x 360 cm), which sold for $78,000 against a pre-sale estimate of $60,000-80,000 thereby eclipsing the previous record of $72,000 for the similar sized Awelye 2004 that had sold in November 2006
As expected, average prices on the secondary market vary according to size regardless of quality. Minnie painted a number of major works around 350 x 165 cm in size, which sold at an average of $56,000. However, there is a dramatic drop in average prices with works around 270 x 120 cm having sold for a mean of $18,000, while works averaging 200 x 120 cm sold at around $11,000. Works smaller than 150 x 120 cm regularly sell below $5,000. Moreover, regardless of size, average prices for Minnie have decidedly dropped since her breakthrough years. This is quite a different story from her prices in the primary market. Since her death Dacou re-priced all of her canvasses painted prior to 2002, and today these sell for considerably more than the averages listed above. Over the next few years, expect some spectacular results when the best of these smaller works are offered through auction houses.
With so many ordinary paintings sitting on collector’s walls, the cream of Minnie’s oeuvre will only appear for sale over time. Nevertheless, her recent records have been impressive. She was the 14th most successful artist in 2019. While as expected, many more of Minnie's paintings have appeared since 2020, brought to auction from private collections and reflecting the enthusiasm of buyers in those early years. Most are small paintings, selling for under $5,000. In 2020 alone she sold 33 works to a total of $288, 347, a grand record. Through 2025, 55 works have appeared so far, of which 42 have sold. These works still generate excitement and, interspersed with the occasional remarkable (and usually much larger) piece, in the higher price bracket, Minnie Pwerle retains her enigmatic presence. Since 2002, of 635 works on offer, 434 have sold, still very admirable at 68%.
As with works by all prolific artists, the majority of Minnie Pwerle’s paintings are difficult to critically assess. Most of her smaller works are to be avoided at auction despite their appeal, especially by collectors who have any concerns about investment value. Yet those works bought with judgment and a critical eye should hold their value. With average prices for smaller works well below primary market values, the secondary market may well be the place to pick up a bargain, especially if you fall in love with a painting and are not so concerned about its resale value. Minnie's major works vary in quality but not as great as the smaller pieces. There are enough masterpieces amongst them to ensure that Minnie Pwerle will rate among the greatest of all Aboriginal women painters and prove several of her critics completely wrong about her legacy.
Rank #15Cumulative AAMI 21.58
Annual AAMI rating by year — hover or tap a bar for the exact figure.
How the AAMI rating is calculated
The AAMI (Aboriginal Art Market Index) measures an artist’s auction performance each year. Each annual rating combines the value of works sold (total sales and clearance rate), the number of works offered, and the average price achieved — with adjustments that temper thin trading years and a rising annual price threshold, so results stay comparable over time. The yearly ratings are added together into an artist’s Cumulative AAMI score, which determines their rank in the index.